正畸医生与正畸患者对面部美学的评价及其差别

›› 2014, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (6): 450-453.

正畸医生与正畸患者对面部美学的评价及其差别

周丝思¹,林新平²

1. 浙江中医药大学
2. 杭州口腔医院

收稿日期:2013-12-16 修回日期:2014-02-01 出版日期:2014-06-28 发布日期:2014-07-07
通讯作者: 林新平 E-mail:xplinzju@163.com

Comparison of facial aesthetic assessment of orthodontic treatment between orthodontists and patients

¹,

Received:2013-12-16 Revised:2014-02-01 Online:2014-06-28 Published:2014-07-07

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目的通过Q分类法来调查正畸医生与正畸患者对面部美学的评价及其差别,同时调查男性与女性对面部美学的评价及其差别。方法将96例正畸完成后的患者（男、女各48例）临床照片由20名经验丰富的正畸医生（男7名，女13名）和25例正畸患者（男13例，女12例）用Q分类法进行评价。Kappa检验和McNemar检验用来评估正畸医生和正畸患者之间，以及男女之间对面部美学评价是否一致和其差别。结果在对男性面部美观调查中，正畸医师与正畸患者的评价具有较高的一致性，男性与女性的评价具有较高的一致性。在对女性面部美观调查中，正畸医师与正畸患者的评价的一致性较差，男性与女性评价的一致性也较差。结论正畸医师与正畸患者对面部美观的评价基本一致；男性与女性对面部美学的评价基本不一致。

关键词: 面部美学, Q分类, 美学评价

Abstract: Objective To compare the facial aesthetic assessment of orthodontic treatment between orthodontists and orthodontic patients,and between men and women,via Q-sort method subjective evaluation of the facial aesthetics. Methods Q-sort method was used to evaluate the facial aesthetic assessment of 20 experienced orthodontists (7 men,13 women) and 25 patients (13 men and 12 women),through rating clinical photographs of 96 post-orthodontic patients（48 men and 48 women）; Kappa agreement and McNemar test were used to analyze similarities and differences between orthodontists and patients,and between men and women. Results The survey on male facial appearance indicated more similarities shared by orthodontists and orthodontic patients,and higher agreement between men and women; while the survey of female facial appearance,showed more differences between orthodontists and orthodontic patients,with a lower conformity between men and women raters.Men tend to be more satisfied with the facial appearance than women,but the tendency is not obvious. Conclusions Orthodontists and orthodontic patients have a higher conformity in facial appearance assessment; while men and women have lower conformity in facial aesthetic assessment.

Key words: facial aesthetics, Q-sort, aesthetic evaluation

中图分类号:

R783.5

周丝思林新平. 正畸医生与正畸患者对面部美学的评价及其差别[J]. 口腔医学, 2014, 34(6): 450-453.

参考文献

[1]Hunt O,Hepper P,Johnston C,et al.The aesthetic component of the index of orthodontic treatment need validated against lay opinion[J].Eur J Orthod,2002,24(1):53-59
[2]Birkeland K,Katle A,Lvgreen S,et al.Factors influencing thedecision about orthodontic treatmentA longitudinal study among11-and 15-1999-olds and their parents[J]..J Orofac Orthop,1999,60(5):292-307
[3]Trulsson U,Strandmark M,Mohlin B,et al.A qualitative study ofteenagers decisions to undergo orthodontic treatment with fixedappliance[J].J Orthod,2002,29(3):197-204
[4]Romani KL,Agahi F,Nanda R,et al.Evaluation of horizontaland vertical differences in facial profiles by orthodontists and laypeople[J].Angle Orthod,1993,63(3):175-182
[5]Kilpelinen PV,Phillips C,Tulloch JF.Anterior tooth positionand motivation for early treatment[J].Angle Orthod,1993,63(3):171-174
[6]Pabari S，Moles DR，Cunningham SJ.Assessment of motivation and psychological characteristics of adult orthodontic patients[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2011,140(6):72-
[7]Cracel-Nogueira F，Pinho T.Assessment of the perception of smile esthetics by laypersons,dental students and dental practitioners[J].Int Orthod,2013,11(4):44-432
[8] Stephenson W.The study of behavior［M］.Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1953：31-40
[9] Fleiss JL.Statisticalmethodsfor rates and proportions［M］.2nd ed.New York:John Wiley & Sons,1981：54-71
[10]Cox NH,van der Linden FP.Facial harmony[J].Am J Orthod,1971,60(2):175-83
[11]Soh J,Chew MT,Wong HB.Professional assessment of facial profileattractiveness[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2005,128(2):201-205
[12]Faure JC,Rieffe C,Maltha JC.The influence of different facial components of facial aesthetics[J].Eur J Orthod,2002,24(1):1-7
[13]Ricketts RM.Esthetics,environment,and the law of lip relation[J].Am J Orthod,1968,54(4):272-289
[14]Schabel BJ,McNamara JA Jr,Franchi L,et al.Q-sort assessment vs visual analog scale in the evaluation of smile esthetics[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2009,135(4):S61-71
[15]Phillips C,Tulloch C,Dann C.Rating of facial attractiveness[J].Community Dent Oral Epidemiol,1992,20(4):214-220
[16]Kerr WJ,O′donnell JM.Panel perception of facial attractiveness[J].Br J Orthod,1990,17(4):299-304
[17]Zange SE，Ramos AL，Cuoghi OA，et al.Perceptions of laypersons and orthodontists regarding the buccal corridor in long-and short-face individuals[J].Angle Orthod,2011,81(1):86-90
[18]Shaw WC,Richmond S,O′Brien KD,et al.Quality control in orthodontics:indices of orthodontic treatment need and treatment standards[J].Br Dent J,1991,170(3):107-112
[19]Kiekens RM,Maltha JC,vant Hof MA,et al.A measuring system for facial aesthetics in Caucasian adolescents:reproducibility andvalidity[J].Eur J Orthod,2005,27(6):579-584