再治疗根管再预备过程对根管壁损伤的影响

›› 2015, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (8): 685-687.

再治疗根管再预备过程对根管壁损伤的影响

张凌¹,朱琳琳²,文成超²,张梦龙²

1. 中国医科大学口腔医学院
2. 中国医科大学口腔医学院牙体牙髓病科

收稿日期:2014-04-08 修回日期:2014-09-02 出版日期:2015-08-28 发布日期:2015-08-14
通讯作者: 张凌 E-mail:1544189325@QQ.com

Influence of root canal retreatment procedures on the appearance of defects on the root canal walls

Received:2014-04-08 Revised:2014-09-02 Online:2015-08-28 Published:2015-08-14
Contact: Ling Zhang E-mail:1544189325@QQ.com

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目的研究再治疗术根管再预备对根管壁损伤的影响。方法 160颗正畸拔除的前磨牙随机分为2组，各80颗，分别在拔除1个月(A组)，半年后(B组)行根管治疗、再治疗； A组再随机分为根管治疗组（A1组）再治疗组（A2组），每组40颗，B组同样分为根管治疗组（B1组）再治疗组（B2组）；A2和B2组又分为单独ProTaper再治疗锉组(A21、B21)、ProTaper再治疗锉辅助使用氯仿组(A22、B22)。牙根在显微镜下切断并检查。结果再治疗组的根管壁损伤明显高于根管治疗组；与ProTaper再治疗锉单独使用比较，辅助使用氯仿组有明显的差异，使用氯仿可以减少再预备过程对根管壁的损伤。结论根管再治疗会比根管治疗造成更多的根管损伤。当评估根管再治疗时，应考虑牙壁损伤的潜在风险。

关键词: 再治疗, 镍-钛锉, 牙本质

Abstract: Objective To explore the influence of root canal retreatment procedures on the appearance of defects on the root canal walls.Methods One hundred and sixty premolars extracted for orthodontics were randomly divided into two groups with 80 in each group.They were treated and retreated a month（A group） and half a year(B group) after extraction.Forty teeth （A1 group）in A group were treated and the other 40 (A2 group) were retreated at random,and B group was divided into B1 group and B2 group in the same way.Among retreated teeth,twenty teeth filling materials were removed by ProTaper retreatment files only(A21 group，B21 group) and the other twenty teeth were removed by ProTaper retreatment files with chloroform（A22 group，B22 group）.Roots were then sectioned and inspected under a microscope.Results Retreatment groups showed significantly more defects than the initial treatment group.There was difference in the appearance of defects after retreatment between ProTaper retreatment files only group and chloroformsupplied group.Conclusions Retreatment procedures result in more defects than initial treatment.When assessing the outcomes of endodontic retreatment,the substantial damage to the root canal walls should be considered.

Key words: retreatment, nickel-titanium files, root dentin

中图分类号:

R780.1

张凌朱琳琳文成超张梦龙. 再治疗根管再预备过程对根管壁损伤的影响[J]. 口腔医学, 2015, 35(8): 685-687.

参考文献

[1]Shemesh H,Alida C,Roeleveld DS,et al.Damage to Root Dentin During Retreatment Procedures[J].Endod,2011,37(1):63-66
[2]Shemesh H,Bier CA,Wu MK,et al.The effects of canal preparation and filling on the incidence of dentinal defects[J].Int Endod,2009,42(3):208-213
[3]Rdig T,Kupis J,Konietschke F,et al.Comparison of hand and rotary instrumentation for removing guttapercha from previously treated curved root canals:a microcomputed tomography study[J].Int Endod,2014,47(2):173-182
[4]Inan U,Aydin C.Comparison of cyclic fatigue resistance of three different rotary nickeltitanium instruments designed forretreatment[J].Endod,2012,38(1):108-111
[5]Takahashi CM,Cunha RS,Martin AS,et al.In vitro evaluation of the effectiveness of ProTaper universal rotary retreatment system for guttapercha removal with or without a solvent[J].Endod,2009,35(10):1580-1583
[6]Shemesh H,Wesselink PR,Wu MK,et al.Incidence of dentinal defects after root canal filling procedures[J].Int Endod,2010,43(8):995-1000
[7]朱琳琳，朱晓华.牙隐裂诊断和治疗[J].中国实用口腔科杂志,2012,5(11):702-704
[8]Akpnar KE,Altunba D,Kutarc A.The efficacy of two rotary NiTi instruments and Hfiles to remove guttapercha from root canals[J].Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal,2012,17(3):506-511
[9]Mittal N,Jain J.Spiral computed tomography assessment of the efficacy of different rotary versus hand retreatment system[J].Conserv Dent,2014,17(1):8-12
[10]Bier CA,Shemesh H,TanomaruFilho M,et al.The ability of different nickeltitanium rotary instruments to induce dentinal damage during canal preparation[J].Endod,2009,35（3）:236-238
[11]Xu LL,Zhang L,Zhou XD,et al.Residual filling material in dentinal tubules after guttapercha removal observed with scanning electron microscopy[J].Endod,2012,38(3):293-296
[12]Zvi M,Michael S,Anda K.The role of mechanical instrumentation in the cleaning of root canals[J].Endodontic Topics,2013,29(1):87-109
[13]Abramovitz S,Relles B,Baransi B,et al.The effectiveness of a selfadjusting file to remove residual guttapercha after retreatment with rotary files[J].Intern Endod,2012,45(4):386-392
[14]Markus H,Ya S.Evolution of nickeltitanium instruments:from past to future[J].Endodontic Topics,2013,29(1):3-17
[15]Ersev H,Yilmaz B,Dinol ME,et al.The efficacy of ProTaper Universal rotary retreatment instrumentation to remove single guttapercha cones cemented with several endodontic sealers[J].Int Endod,2012,45(8):756-762
[16]Topuo〖AKgˇD〗lu HS,Demirbuga S,Tuncay ,et al.The effects of Mtwo,REndo,and DRaCe retreatment instruments on the incidence of dentinal defects during the removal of root canal filling material[J].Endod,2014,40(2):266-270